We Buy…
Jewelry, Gold, Coins, Platinium, and Diamonds…
Custom Castings
We offer castings from multiple vendors.
Bridal Sets
Selection of unique wedding and engagement rings.
Online Reviews
Read what people have said or add your own.
Specializing in creating a personal experience for our customers.
We are a full service fine jewelry store located in Lakewood, Ohio. We offer a large selection of colored stone and diamond jewelry. Please look through our online catalog to view some of our merchandise. This catalog represents only a small portion of our extensive jewelry inventory. Contact us for more information.
Call us Today! (216) 221-1434.
New Arrivals
Featured Items
Designers
We are proud to feature these designers
@broestlwallis
Follow us on Instagram
Enjoy the long weekend, everyone! 🇺🇸🎆🎇
Just arrived a beautiful Emerald and Diamond ring. #emerald #broestlwallis
NEW to our store this beautiful Blue Topaz pendant and chain. #broestlwallis. #bluetopaz
We have a great selection of 14k white and yellow gold crosses to commemorate any special event. #broestlwallis #crosspendants
The birthstone for March is Aquamarine. It is a beautiful shade of blue. #broestlwallis #aquamarine
Wear your stackable rings to create your very own style. #stackables #broestlwallis
Amethyst is the birthstone for February. We have a wonderful selection at our store in Lakewood Ohio. #amethyst #broestlwallis #birthstone
The birthstone for February is Amethyst. Celebrate that special birthday with a beautiful piece of jewelry.
#february #broestlandwallis #amethystjewelry
Joyce Kennedy
17:39 01 Jul 22
The clasp on my gold hoop earring broke off. I brought it in and they fixed it. It looks good as new.
Diane Strunak
20:37 23 Jun 22
I've had a few heirloom jewelry pieces transformed by Broestl & Wallace. Jeff also created a beautiful ring for me,... which I absolutely love!read more
Leslie Scaletta
18:39 03 May 22
I have been a customer for 30 years. My jewelry is stunning! I always receive compliments from strangers and friends.... The quality is beyond compare and I am treated like family. Jeff Broestl is patient, kind and a quality craftsman. They helped all four of my children custom design their wedding sets. Everyone I have ever recommended shop there has chosen them as their jeweler. They are a five star plus business!read more
william dominick
19:10 04 Apr 22
I saw a add for a watch i liked they found it ,ordered it, fit itGreat doing business with them
Amanda Cramer
17:10 22 Mar 22
I came into this store to have a prong on my engagement ring fixed. The jeweler stopped what he was doing and did it... for me while I waited. He also cleaned my ring, my wedding band, and another ring I had on. All of this for $10, no matter how much I told him he should charge more. Amazing service!read more
Margaret Bajic
15:31 11 Feb 22
The diamond in my engagement ring fell out, and I quickly wanted it repaired. I went to one jeweler who said I needed a... new setting and quoted me $400 (or more) to repair it. I decided I wanted a second opinion so came to Broestl & Wallis, where Jeff quoted half that price. I went in on a Tuesday and he had it fixed by Thursday. I specifically want to call out that he knew I was going out of town on Friday, so he worked hard to make sure I had it done before I left town. My ring is as beautiful as ever! I also want to say the other staff was extremely friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend!read more
Colleen Alletto
21:44 01 Nov 21
We have been coming to Jeff for years now and could not possibly say how perfect each and every experience has been. ... He is so incredibly talented, thoughtful, professional and fun to work with. There have been a few custom pieces he has made for us and he puts his whole heart into them. Jeff has also repaired a few family heirlooms to perfection. Everything in the store is beautiful!!!read more
Suzanne Healy
14:08 22 Sep 21
After 25 years my engagement ring needed some love and attention. I went to another local jeweler who gave me an... outrageous estimate for a repair. Not only that but they damaged my ring in the process by "cleaning" it (which they were not asked to do). No apology other than, it happens. So, my ring sat in a drawer for over a year as I couldn't afford to have it repaired.Enter Broestl. I searched for another jeweler that was highly recommended and found them. I am thrilled to death that I did. The staff here was amazingly helpful, welcoming, and friendly. The owner/jeweler was also amazingly helpful, and friendly -- but above and beyond all else, he was fair in his assessment of the repair that needed to be done and quoted me 1/3 of what the original establishment had. Needless to say, I immediately said yes.I picked up my ring yesterday and it was beautiful. He did a phenomenal job of essentially rebuilding the ring to not only fix the crack in the band, but strengthen the prongs and inset diamonds. After polishing it up, when I arrived to collect it -- it looked like a brand new ring. I had tears in my eyes when I was able to finally put it back on my finger after so long.Thank you Broestl for your wonderful service, quality craftsmanship, and reasonable and fair pricing. I will be coming to you for all of our families fine jewelry purchases in the future!read more
Kyle Crane
16:08 11 Jun 21
Easily the nicest, most accommodating people, in all of Lakewood! Highly recommend them.
J C
20:56 07 Oct 20
For any guys out there seeking an engagement ring, look no further. Jeff was the best! Knowing very little about... jewelry, I was nervous going into it but immediately knew I was in great hands. Jeff and his team were patient with me throughout the whole process and determined to find the right ring for me. Ultimately we found the perfect stone well within my budget and the quality was unmatched. My fiancé can't take her eyes off this ring!I could not recommend Broestl & Wallis enough. I never felt any pressure to hurry up and buy. You can easily tell they put a lot of pride in their work and take great care of their customers. They made the whole experience feel special for me and I know they will for you!read more
Joseph Eungard
16:39 01 Oct 20
Very simple repair cuz my watch band broke and they were so great. Treated me like someone buying an expensive diamond... even though it was a small job. Thank you so much!!Definitely recommend.Thanks again.Joeread more
G C
22:45 27 Sep 20
I recently had my cross repaired at this establishment. The people were nice and the job looks very well done. I... definitely recommend this shop to others who may need jewellery repaired.read more
Kate Rybak
14:25 21 Sep 20
Love, love, love Broestl & Wallis. They made our wedding rings and have kept them looking as beautiful as the day we... got them. I refer everyone here.read more
Janet Delaney
18:03 18 Feb 20
Great Jewelry store for many years. I had a special ring from my late MotherDesigned special for me and is beautiful... and the customer service is the best. I take my watches there for new batteries too. It’s like going back in time the way stores used to be.read more
Amanda C.
2022-03-22 10:11:11
I came into this store to have a prong on my engagement ring fixed. The jeweler stopped what he was doing and did it for me while I waited. He also cleaned...
KJ M.
2021-10-23 09:00:57
Truly fantastic jeweler. I cannot recommend enough. If you're in the market for anything shiny, this is the place. Great quality and fair prices.
Maureen W.
2021-09-30 15:37:27
Jeff is a god-send. He completely fixed my engagement ring after the diamond had fallen out and was put back in crooked by Buchards Jewelery in Berea. I can...
Christiana S.
2021-06-20 16:22:51
Came here to have the batteries on my fairly expensive watch replaced and the whole process was very quick! Everyone at the store had a smile on their face,...
Suzanne E.
2021-05-25 06:58:03
Jeff Broestl is amazing! I came to him with a very specific idea for a custom engagement ring. The ring incorporated vintage features, such as a filigree...
Jim H.
2020-09-20 14:01:48
This jewelry store is in our neighborhood and I had them make a custom piece for my wife about 15 years ago, and they knocked it out of the park. Just...
Agnes I.
2020-03-06 03:11:13
I have been waiting to fix my watch battery for YEARS now so I finally stopped being lazy and took my watch over to Broestl and Wallis Fine Jewelers....
Zachary P.
2019-08-21 17:47:05
Came here looking for a wedding gift for my wife. I wanted to work with a local jeweler, and wasn't sure where to go. I had a prior bad experience with a...